On April 26, 2025, the stage was set at M.S. 224/I.S. 343 in the heart of the South Bronx, where the Democratic candidates vying for New York City’s 8th Council District squared off in a highly anticipated forum. This district, which encompasses key areas of the South Bronx and East Harlem, is in the midst of an intense political battle as residents prepare to choose their next representative in the City Council.
The evening, brought together by South Bronx Unite and other organizations, had a diverse array of candidates, each with distinct backgrounds and visions for the future of this community. From activists and attorneys to political staffers and community board members, the candidates showcased a blend of experience and passion, all vying for the opportunity to represent the people of District 8.
The candidate panelists included Elsie Encarnacion, Council Member Ayala’s current chief of staff; Nicholas Reyes, a State Committee Member for the 68th Assembly District; Wilfredo Lopez, a nonprofit attorney; Raymond Santana, one of the exonerated Central Park Five; and Clarisa Alayeto, Chair of Community Board 1.
The issues discussed at the forum were familiar to many who have long felt the pressures of city life: housing affordability, rising crime rates, job creation, economic opportunities, and quality-of-life concerns. Each candidate took turns addressing these critical issues, offering solutions and perspectives from their unique vantage points.
However, the tension in the room reached a boiling point when Wilfredo Lopez, one of the frontrunners in the race, was sharply criticized for his campaign’s staggering $1.4 million war chest. Critics in the audience wasted no time voicing their disdain, accusing Lopez of being “bought off” by special interest groups and powerful developers. Many attendees felt that his financial backing indicated a potential conflict of interest, suggesting that his positions might favor corporate interests over those of working-class residents.
In stark contrast, the event remained relatively calm for most of the afternoon, with the crowd keeping its composure despite the rising tensions. The debates were heated, but the tone remained civil—until Lopez’s campaign funding became the center of controversy.
Among those in attendance was outgoing City Councilwoman Diana Ayala, who is term-limited and will be stepping down at the end of her term in 2025. Ayala’s presence underscored the significance of the event, as District 8 will soon be in search of a new leader to carry forward her work.
Also present was Tyreek Goodman, the Conservative and Republican challenger who currently serves as the District Leader for the 84th Assembly District. Goodman didn’t mince words, offering a blunt critique of the Democratic candidates’ platforms. “They all say the same thing,” Goodman remarked, “but very little on what real change they’re actually willing to bring.” His comment struck a chord with some in the crowd, who echoed his sentiment about the lack of concrete proposals.
As the afternoon came to a close, it was clear that District 8’s race for the City Council seat is far from decided. The people in the community are passionate, and their concerns—housing, crime, and economic opportunity—are deeply important to them. The future of Mott Haven and East Harlem remains uncertain, but one thing is for sure: it’s in the people’s hands to decide and shape its future.
