Cancer Detection & Man’s Best Friend

Published on November 15, 2011, 9:28 pm
FavoriteLoadingAdd to favorites 5 mins

Dogs are loyal, playful, loving and sometimes cute as a button. It’s no wonder we love them (some of us more than others, to be sure).

Dogs were likely one of the very first animals we humans domesticated. They have been sitting around our campfires for a very long time, indeed. We train our dogs to sit, shake and lie down. It also could be said the dogs train us to dispense kibbles, rawhide treats, and scratches behind the ears. What matters is not which side comes out ahead in the exchange, I like to think, but that both sides benefit from our association.
Recently I had occasion to read aloud a news report to my “Labrador mix” as he lay stretched out near my feet one evening. Buster Brown came from the dog pound where he was listed as a Lab mix, although in truth the vet and I agree he has so many different influences in him it is rather misleading to name just one. Still, because he will retrieve sticks I throw into the water, I dignify his existence by thinking of him as predominately a Labrador Retriever. And he’s content with that description.
The story I read aloud originated in Germany where a study was done with dogs who have been trained to indicate when they smell chemicals emitted by cancer cells in the human body. This isn ot the first such study to be done, but it confirmed what earlier ones had shown: dogs can be good early warning detectors of malignancies within us people.
The German study used two German shepherds (naturally), an Australian shepherd and one Labrador retriever. (Buster, ofcourse, was pleased to hear about that fourth dog’s participation in the study.) The dogs were trained to lie down when they smelled lung cancer. The dogs were just house-dogs, and the training did not go much beyond that used in typical puppy school. So it is likely that what the four dogs could do, so could my Buster and your Fido, too.
The canines in the study were given test tubes containing people’s breath samples, both healthy subjects and those who had lung cancer. The dogs had been trained to lie down when they smelled traces of lung cancer and touch the vials with their noses. About 70 percent of the time, the dogs successfully identified patient known to have lung cancer.
The study is not the first of this type to have been done. Other studies with dogs have tested their ability to detectbreast cancer, colon cancer, skin cancer and more. Some studies have had much higher detection rates than 70 percent, too.
Clearly dogs can tumble to just a tiny trace of chemicals associated with cancer cells. I have read that dogs have more neurons running from the nose to the brain than we people do, and a larger proportion of the dog brain is devoted to processing information from the nose than is the case in our noggins.
The fact that dogs can smell malignancies would seem to indicate the cancers create particular chemicals that are otherwise not in our bodies. Exactly what those compounds are remains a mystery. In other words, we can say the dogs in Germany did pretty well at detecting lung cancer, but we do not know what chemicals in the test tube vials were the ones the dogs responded to. And, of course, the dogs cannot tell us that part of the story.
It is interesting to speculate why it took us so long to ask Fido’s help in cancer detection. I think it is partly because of the way we view science and all things medical. We think that the best scientific or medical devices will be large and expensive machines. Likely they’ll be scary, too, at least if you have to spend time with one as a patient.
It’s just outside our framework of thinking to imagine that the mutt under the kitchen table at home could do as well as a chemical detector designed by an engineer and costing tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars.
As a friend of mine in graduate school used to say, “Scientific instruments should be big, noisy, scary and cold.”
Or not!


Jonas Bronck is the pseudonym under which we publish and manage the content and operations of The Bronx Daily.™ | - the largest daily news publication in the borough of "the" Bronx with over 1.5 million annual readers. Publishing under the alias Jonas Bronck is our humble way of paying tribute to the person, whose name lives on in the name of our beloved borough.