What does it truly mean to say that “all men are created equal?” Nearly two and a half centuries after those words were first written, they continue to stand at the heart of the American identity. They shape how the nation understands freedom, citizenship, and belonging. Yet from the very beginning, that promise has also been challenged, stretched, and redefined through struggle, sacrifice, and the steady pressure of voices demanding to be heard.
Equality in America has never been a finished achievement. It has been an aspiration, a declaration of intent, and at times a contradiction. The nation was founded on ideals that proclaimed universal rights, even as entire groups of people were excluded from those rights in practice. This tension between principle and reality has shaped American history more than any single law, election, or war.
The Community Conversation Becoming America, part of Humanities New York’s Speaking of Revolution series, invites participants into that long and unfinished dialogue. It asks Americans to examine equality not as a static phrase carved into parchment, but as a living commitment—one that must be tested, renewed, and defended by every generation.
As a shared point of reflection, participants turn to Langston Hughes’s powerful poem, Let America Be America Again. Written during the Great Depression, Hughes confronts the nation with an uncomfortable truth: that the America promised in its founding words had not yet become reality for millions of its people. His verses echo with the voices of laborers, immigrants, Black Americans, and the working poor—those whose dreams were postponed, denied, or broken, even as the language of freedom rang out around them.
Hughes does not reject the American promise. Instead, he demands that the nation live up to it. His poem asks whether America can still become what it claimed to be—and what sacrifices, reckonings, and changes that would require. It challenges readers to see equality not as a completed chapter of history, but as a responsibility that continues into the present.
Through close reading, careful listening, and thoughtful discussion, Becoming America creates space for participants to reflect on how ideals of equality have shaped American life, where they have fallen short, and why they remain central to democratic renewal today. These conversations are not simply about the past; they are about the present moment and the future that is being shaped by today’s choices.
In revisiting the nation’s founding promise, Becoming America reminds us that democracy is not sustained by words alone. It is sustained by action, accountability, and the willingness of each generation to confront injustice, widen inclusion, and insist that the promise of equality belongs to everyone.
America, the conversation suggests, is not something that was completed in 1776. It is something that is still becoming.
The event will take place on Wednesday, January 14, 2026, between the hours of 5:30 p.m. and 6:45 p.m. (doors open at 5:00p.m.), at the Stavros Niarchos Foundation Library, 455 5th Avenue, Manhattan, NY 10016.
To register, please visit here.
About the Humanities New York
Founded in 1975 with the support of the National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH), Humanities New York (HNY) is one of 56 state and jurisdictional humanities councils. As a not-for-profit, non-partisan organization, we receive funding from private donations, foundations, and institutions in addition to the federal government.
Humanities New York relies on contributions to fund public programming across NYS. A gift to HNY is a gift to the statewide cultural sector. We are grateful for your support.
Featured image credit: DepositPhotos.com
