Lawsuit Against City, NYPD For Illegally Arresting & Detaining New Yorkers For Low-Level Offenses

Published on April 14, 2021, 8:49 pm
FavoriteLoadingAdd to favorites 5 mins

The Legal Aid Society and Debevoise & Plimpton LLP filed a lawsuit in New York State Supreme Court today against the City of New York, the New York City Police Department (NYPD), and named and unnamed NYPD officers on behalf of five plaintiffs who were unlawfully arrested and detained on low-level offenses instead of receiving an appearance ticket as prescribed by law during the George Floyd demonstrations last summer. This lawsuit petitions the Court to enjoin the NYPD from continuing to violate the law, award compensatory damages to Plaintiffs, and other relief as the Court deems just and proper.

In January 2020, New York State enacted legislation to eliminate unnecessary arrests, minimize the amount of time that New Yorkers accused of crimes may be detained, and reduce an overcrowded detention system.

Part of the legislation amended New York Criminal Procedure Law to mandate that, for violations, infractions, misdemeanors, and certain class E felonies, police officers issue appearance tickets at the point of a police encounter rather than arrest individuals suspected of committing such offenses.

The NYPD, however, has blatantly disregarded the law by continuing to exercise unfettered discretion to arrest and take into custody individuals alleged to have engaged in low-level offenses, despite the law’s mandate to issue appearance tickets. As a result of these unlawful arrests, many people spend hours or even days unnecessarily incarcerated, disrupting their lives and jeopardizing their employment and family obligations.

The problem of unnecessary arrests spans a range of low-level criminal enforcement, but was particularly acute during the protests last year, when the NYPD arrested Plaintiffs in this litigation for violating the Mayor’s curfew or for Disorderly Conduct – both of which are low-level offenses (a class B misdemeanor and a violation, respectively) for which an appearance ticket is mandated.

Though all charges against all of the Plaintiffs were dismissed, or were never even filed with a court, the police should have issued appearance tickets for those charges, rather than arrest the Plaintiffs.

Despite the law’s clear mandate to issue appearance tickets, the NYPD unlawfully arrested, handcuffed, and in some instances physically brutalized the Plaintiffs. The NYPD then transported and detained the Plaintiffs in overcrowded, filthy, and overheated vehicles and held them in jail cells inside of police facilities for many hours, where little or no CoViD-19 pandemic precautions were taken.

“For merely observing a protest, the NYPD illegally arrested and detained me for eight hours. I was confined to a packed cell with fifty other people, unable to socially distance, and many people were without masks,” said Lead Plaintiff Charles Douglas. “No one should experience what I went through – the law is designed to prevent these sorts of needless arrests, and the NYPD must be held to account for their egregious flaunting of the law.”

“The NYPD illegally arrested and incarcerated me and hundreds of other demonstrators for low-level offenses instead of issuing appearances tickets as the law requires,” said Plaintiff Julian Gilbert. “This practice unfortunately continues today, and I’m proud to share my story to ensure that the NYPD actually adheres to the law, and so that other New Yorkers are spared from the trauma that I was forced to endure.”

“The law is clear, but the NYPD still overwhelmingly refuses to issue appearance tickets for low-level offenses, instead, processing New Yorkers – the majority from Black and Brown neighborhoods – through the legal system,” said Marlen Bodden, Staff Attorney with the Special Litigation Unit at The Legal Aid Society. “The NYPD is not above the law, and we are asking the court to order the NYPD to follow it or face the consequences.”


About The Legal Aid Society

The Legal Aid Society

The Legal Aid Society exists for one simple yet powerful reason: to ensure that New Yorkers are not denied their right to equal justice because of poverty. For over 140 years, we have protected, defended, and advocated for those who have struggled in silence for far too long. Every day, in every borough, The Legal Aid Society changes the lives of our clients and helps improve our communities.

For more inforation, please visit here.

Jonas Bronck is the pseudonym under which we publish and manage the content and operations of The Bronx Daily.™ | - the largest daily news publication in the borough of "the" Bronx with over 1.5 million annual readers. Publishing under the alias Jonas Bronck is our humble way of paying tribute to the person, whose name lives on in the name of our beloved borough.