Bronx Woman Sues SI Man Over $1M Ticket

Published on November 22, 2014, 3:02 pm
FavoriteLoadingAdd to favorites 5 mins

Michael Simmons said he felt lucky when he bought a Powerball ticket last year that won him a nifty $1 million, according to a statement released by the state Lottery press office.

But luck had nothing to do with the Mariners Harbor resident’s good fortune, contends a lawsuit filed Thursday by a Bronx woman.

Mercedes Rosario alleges she purchased the winning ducat from a local bodega and her former live-in boyfriend wrongfully took it and gave it to Simmons, contends her suit, filed in Bronx state Supreme Court.

Simmons is the boss of Ms. Rosario’s ex, Alexis Seda, said her lawyer, Marc H. Wasserman of Suffolk County.

Asked why Seda would have given the windfall ticket to Simmons, Wasserman responded, “That’s the million-dollar question.”

With the ticket’s ownership now being contested, a Bronx justice on Thursday ordered Simmons’ bank accounts frozen, along with the lottery proceeds.

Ms. Rosario seeks $1 million in damages.

According to Wasserman and Ms. Rosario’s civil complaint, she bought the ticket from a bodega on Unionport Road in the Bronx on February 8, 2013.

The drawing was held on Feb. 9, the Lottery’s website shows. The ticket matched the first five numbers drawn, but not the Powerball number.

Still, it was good enough for a cool million dollars.

Ms. Rosario’s complaint alleges Seda, 56, took the ticket “without (her) authorization” and gave it to Simmons.

Simmons employs Seda at Malmek Glass Contracting, said Wasserman.

The company is an architectural glass, metal and window contractor, says its website, which lists addresses in Mariners Harbor and Yonkers.

Wasserman said his client has lived under the “constant threat and fear of both Seda and Simmons to ever come forward as the rightful owner of the ticket.”

She no longer resides with Seda, having moved out last month, he said.

That is when she began seeking civil redress.

No criminal charges have been filed.

Simmons, 49, cashed in the ticket and on March 19, 2013, was awarded the prize.

In a release that day, the Lottery press office said Simmons bought the winning ticket on February 8, 2013 at a grocery store on Unionport Road in Bronx.

“I normally only play when the jackpots get really high,” the press release quoted Simmons as saying. “I felt lucky that day so I decided to play Powerball. I was actually pretty calm when I realized I just won $1 million.”

Simmons was to receive a lump-sum payment of $623,040 after required withholdings, said the press release.

Simmons said he would use the cash to help pay his kids’ tuition, the press release said.

In court briefs, Simmons and Seda denied Ms. Rosario’s claim.

Seda said he sent Ms. Rosario to the local bodega on February 9, 2013, to buy him Mega Lotto and Powerball tickets. He said she had bought his lottery tickets “for many years.”

Seda said Ms. Rosario called him on February 11, 2013 while he was heading home and told him he had won $1 million.

Seda said he gave Simmons the winning ticket on February 15, 2013, although his affidavit offers no explanation for the largesse.

Simmons’ affidavit also says Seda, whom he knows as a friend and business associate for 10 years, handed him the ticket on February 15, 2013.

“Alexis Seda gave me the lottery ticket, stating that he wanted me to have the lottery ticket,” said the affidavit.

It, too, provides no reason why.

Simmons said he was “casually acquainted” with Ms. Rosario and knew she was in a romantic relationship with Seda.

Last month, prior to filing the lawsuit, Wasserman petitioned the court to freeze Simmons’ bank accounts, until a judge determines the lottery ticket’s rightful owner.

At a hearing Thursday, Justice Julia I. Rodriguez temporarily froze Simmons’ savings and checking accounts, along with any of the lottery proceeds.

She did not rule on Ms. Rosario’s ownership claim.

Attempts to reach Simmons, Seda and their lawyer were unsuccessful.


Jonas Bronck is the pseudonym under which we publish and manage the content and operations of The Bronx Daily.™ | - the largest daily news publication in the borough of "the" Bronx with over 1.5 million annual readers. Publishing under the alias Jonas Bronck is our humble way of paying tribute to the person, whose name lives on in the name of our beloved borough.